Best Pizza in Fernandina Beach

Q: What styles of pizza are available in Fernandina Beach?

You'll find 17 spots serving everything from New York thin-crust to Neapolitan wood-fired and Detroit-style square slices. Most menus include both classic and creative toppings.

Q: Can I get good pizza for takeout in Fernandina Beach?

Absolutely — many of the 17 pizzerias in Fernandina Beach do roaring takeout business and pack boxes perfectly. Check which places offer same-day orders or delivery through their listings.

Q: Do pizza places in Fernandina Beach take reservations?

It depends on the spot. Some welcome walk-ins, others take reservations for groups. Check individual listing details or call ahead, especially on weekends.

Craving pizza in Fernandina Beach? Browse 17 top-rated pizza spots with photos and menus.

Whether you want a quick slice or a sit-down wood-fired pie, Fernandina Beach has 17 pizza spots worth trying. Styles range from thin-crust Neapolitan to loaded New York slices — most offer takeout if the beach is calling.

Closed

DeCicco's Pizzeria

76000 William Burgess Blvd

4.9

DeCicco's Pizzeria serves classic Italian-style pizzas with a menu that highlights their hand-tossed dough and wood-fired oven technique. The Margherita pizza stands out, featuring fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomato sauce that captures traditional flavors. Alongside pizza, they offer Italian appetizers and salads that round out the meal. The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating, creating a relaxed and inviting atmosphere for lunch or dinner. The dining experience is straightforward and comfortable, appealing to families and groups looking to enjoy a casual Italian meal.

Closed

Pizza Street Kitchen

105 S 3rd St

4.8

Pizza Street Kitchen offers classic Italian dishes centered around their hand-tossed pizzas baked in a traditional stone oven. One popular choice is their Margherita pizza, topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and basil that captures simple, authentic flavors. The restaurant has a casual and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a relaxed meal with friends or family. The open kitchen lets you watch the pizza-making process, adding a bit of entertainment to your dining experience.

Closed

Townies Pizzeria

819 T.J. Courson Rd

4.7

Laid-back pizzeria offering wings, subs, and creative pies with dine-in and delivery.

Closed

Moon River Pizza

925 S 14th St

4.6

Funky, local pizza joint known for giant slices, fresh ingredients, and a laid-back vibe.

Closed

Black Cat Pizzeria

660 S 8th St

4.5

Local pizzeria serving hand-tossed pies, pasta, wings, and more in a friendly setting.

Closed

Coastal Pizza

1916 S 14th St Suite 3

4.5

Locally owned pizzeria offering beach-style pies, subs, and wings near the coast.

Closed

Arte Pizza

109 N 3rd St

4.3

Artisan pizza and Italian comfort food in a cozy, laid-back space.

Closed

Kunst Pizza

1408 Lewis St

4.3

Trendy pizza joint serving artisan pies, fresh salads, and a great selection of craft beers.

Open Now

Dominos Pizza

1916 S 14th St

4.2

Fast, reliable chain for carryout and delivery pizzas and sides.

Closed

Natural Slice Pizza Shop

1896 S 14th St

4.2

Surf-style pizzeria with local vibes, fresh ingredients, and a casual coastal atmosphere.

Closed

OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café

231 N Fletcher Ave

4.2

Local pizza café offering Italian classics, wings, and sandwiches in a family-friendly atmosphere.

Closed

V Pizza

2709 Sadler Rd

4.2

Wood-fired pizzas, wings, and Italian favorites with local beer and outdoor seating.

Raphael's Italian Pizzeria

Raphael's Italian Pizzeria is a popular mobile food truck primarily operating throughout Nassau County, Florida, and neighboring areas. Known for its yellow truck trailer, it serves fresh, hot, Neapolitan-style pizza by the slice and whole pie, alongside classic Italian comfort

Closed

Olive Cove Italian Kitchen

463646 FL-200

4.7

Olive Cove Italian Kitchen serves traditional Italian dishes with a straightforward approach. Their wood-fired pizzas, especially the Margherita with fresh mozzarella and basil, stand out alongside classic pasta plates like fettuccine Alfredo. They also offer Italian sandwiches and a selection of Italian wines to pair with your meal. The dining space offers a relaxed indoor setting where guests can enjoy a casual meal. The atmosphere is welcoming and comfortable, making it easy to settle in for lunch or dinner.

Closed

First Love Brew Pub

Fernandina Beach

4.8

Community-focused microbrewery with ~20 rotating taps, pizza, wings; relaxed indoor/outdoor seating under a tree; local favorite.

Explore More in Fernandina Beach

Best Italian Restaurants in Fernandina Beach

Cheap Eats in Fernandina Beach

Best Takeout in Fernandina Beach

Family-Friendly Restaurants in Fernandina Beach

Best Restaurants in Fernandina Beach

Promote Your Business in Fernandina Beach

Things to Do in Fernandina Beach

Restaurant Marketing in Fernandina Beach

Date Night Ideas in Fernandina Beach

Frequently Asked Questions

What styles of pizza are available in Fernandina Beach?

Can I get good pizza for takeout in Fernandina Beach?

Do pizza places in Fernandina Beach take reservations?