Best Pizza in St Simons Island

Q: What styles of pizza are available in St Simons Island?

You'll find 25 spots serving everything from New York thin-crust to Neapolitan wood-fired and Detroit-style square slices. Most menus include both classic and creative toppings.

Q: Can I get good pizza for takeout in St Simons Island?

Absolutely — many of the 25 pizzerias in St Simons Island do roaring takeout business and pack boxes perfectly. Check which places offer same-day orders or delivery through their listings.

Q: Do pizza places in St Simons Island take reservations?

It depends on the spot. Some welcome walk-ins, others take reservations for groups. Check individual listing details or call ahead, especially on weekends.

Craving pizza in St Simons Island? Browse 25 top-rated pizza spots with photos and menus.

Whether you want a quick slice or a sit-down wood-fired pie, St Simons Island has 25 pizza spots worth trying. Styles range from thin-crust Neapolitan to loaded New York slices — most offer takeout if the beach is calling.

Closed

Arte Pizza

4.6

Arte Pizza Located in the heart of Historic Downtown Brunswick, Arte Pizza delivers an authentic Italian dining experience centered around wood-fired, old-world–style pizza and fresh, made-from-scratch dishes. Known for its crispy, perfectly balanced crust and high-quality ingredients, the menu features everything from handcrafted pizzas and calzones to house-made pastas, paninis, and fresh salads. Beyond pizza, guests can enjoy favorites like shrimp pasta, chicken parmesan, and specialty salads, along with beer and wine in a cozy, casual setting. Whether grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a relaxed meal, Arte Pizza offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that blends traditional Italian flavors with a laid-back downtown vibe. Why travelers love it: Authentic wood-fired pizza, fresh ingredients, generous portions, and a welcoming, casual atmosphere that makes it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors exploring downtown Brunswick.

Closed

CJ's Italian Restaurant

4.4

CJ’s Italian Restaurant is a longtime St. Simons Island favorite serving authentic, made-from-scratch Italian comfort food in a cozy, casual setting. Established in 1988, it’s known for its handcrafted pizzas, house-made sauces, and classic dishes that deliver an old-school, family-style dining experience. The menu features a wide variety of options including hand-tossed and deep-dish pizzas, baked pastas, chicken parmesan, strombolis, and fresh salads, all made with quality ingredients and bold flavors. Generous portions and build-your-own options make it a go-to for families and groups. With its relaxed atmosphere and strong local following, CJ’s is a reliable choice for both dine-in and takeout. Why travelers love it: Authentic Italian flavors, standout pizzas, generous portions, and a casual, family-friendly vibe that makes it a true island staple.

Open Now

Domino's Pizza

4.2

Delivers classic pizzas, oven-baked pasta, wings, and cheesy sides via convenient carryout or delivery with local deals.

Closed

$$$

Bromelli Boys Pizzeria

4.5

Broomelli Boys Pizzeria in Brunswick is a family-owned favorite serving hand-tossed pizzas like the Classic, Flyin’ Hawaiian, and Margherita, along with wings, calzones, and fresh salads. Guests can enjoy both indoor and outdoor seating, making it a great spot to relax with family or friends. Known for its welcoming vibe and hearty portions, it’s a go-to pizza place for locals and visitors alike.

Closed

Savannah Pizza Company BW

1248 Chapel Crossing Rd

4.1

Savannah Pizza Company BW serves up classic and creative pizzas that blend traditional flavors with unique twists. One standout is their signature Margherita pizza topped with ripe tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a great spot to relax with friends or family. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a full meal, the laid-back vibe adds to the overall experience.

Closed

$$$

Pizza Inn-Brunswick

4.5

Pizza Inn in Brunswick offers a favorite hometown-style buffet and menu featuring crispy original thin-crust pizzas, hearty pasta, salads, and inventive offerings like Taco Pizza and sweet dessert “Pizzert.” Whether you’re in for a quick carryout or enjoying their all-day buffet, every dish is handmade with fresh dough and signature sauce. Known for welcoming value and comfort food, Pizza Inn brings both nostalgia and satisfying flavor to the table.

Closed

$$$

Fox's Pizza Den Brunswick

4.5

Fox’s Pizza Den in Brunswick serves up hand-tossed pies with crowd favorites like the Buffalo Chicken, Meat Supreme, and Bacon Double Cheeseburger pizzas. Guests also love their cheesy strombolis, hoagies, wings, and mac-and-cheese bites for a hearty, casual meal. Known for generous portions and a friendly neighborhood vibe, it’s a go-to spot for some of the best pizza in town.

Closed

Fox's Den Pizza

4.4

A cozy, family‑friendly pizzeria serving hand‑tossed gourmet pizzas, hoagies, strombolis, wings, and sides for dine‑in, takeout, and delivery.

Closed

$$$

Red Bug Motor's Pizza & Pub

4.2

Red Bug Motors Pizza & Pub serves up scratch-made pizzas, pastas, calzones, wings, and sandwiches in a warm, cozy setting that feels more like an old-world pub than a pizza joint. In operation for over a decade under the same ownership, it’s known for fresh ingredients, friendly service, and a community atmosphere. With dine-in, takeout, and islandwide delivery (excluding beaches), it’s a go-to spot whether you’re walking off the beach or looking for a place to unwind over great food.

Closing Soon · 53min

Little Caesars Pizza-Brunswick

3.5

Little Caesars in Brunswick is the go-to for quick, affordable comfort food, offering their signature Hot-N-Ready® pizzas, including popular options like the ExtraMostBestest® pepperoni and cheese, Detroit-Style Deep Dish, and the ever-iconic Crazy Bread®. For a delicious snack, locals rave about the Crazy Puffs—small, hand-held pizza pockets filled with cheese and sauce—or the bold return of the Stuffed Crazy Crust with garlic butter and parmesan topping. This convenient spot is famous for value-focused menu deals and consistently delivers familiar flavor with its handy Pizza Portal® pickup service.

Closing Soon · 53min

Papa John's Pizza-Brunswick

3.2

Papa John’s in Brunswick is a go-to for fast, familiar pizza favorites, including customizable pizzas, warm breadsticks, wings, Papadias, and sides like cheesy garlic knots. With its focus on convenience and value, this spot serves up quick comfort food with consistently satisfying flavor.

Closed

Sal's Pizza

4.6

Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria on St. Simons offers authentic, thin-crust, Italian-style pizzas in a casual, family-friendly atmosphere—emphasizing local charm, fresh ingredients, and heritage recipes for a delightful coastal dining experience.

Closed

Mellow Mushroom

4.4

A poplular Italian restaurant centrally located in the Pier Village offering amazing dishes, from pizza to bread sticks to wings.

Closed

$$$

Your Pie

4.5

Your Pie, founded in Athens, Georgia in 2008, is the original fast-casual pizza concept built on fresh ingredients and authentic family recipes. Every location hand-tosses dough, uses house-made sauces and dressings, and curates its own local craft beer selection to pair with each pizza. With a focus on hospitality, Your Pie creates a welcoming space for family and friends to gather and enjoy great food together.

Closed

$$$$

Eighty Ocean Kitchen and Bar

4.0

Eighty Ocean Kitchen & Bar on Jekyll Island offers an elevated oceanfront dining experience featuring Southern coastal and Lowcountry-inspired cuisine. Located at the Jekyll Ocean Club, the restaurant highlights fresh seafood, wood-fired pizzas, and thoughtfully crafted dishes made with quality ingredients. With its open-air design, beachfront views, and relaxed yet upscale atmosphere, it’s a perfect spot for everything from casual meals to memorable dining by the ocean.

Explore More in St Simons Island

Best Italian Restaurants in St Simons Island

Cheap Eats in St Simons Island

Best Takeout in St Simons Island

Family-Friendly Restaurants in St Simons Island

Best Restaurants in St Simons Island

Promote Your Business in St Simons Island

Date Night Ideas in St Simons Island

Restaurant Marketing in St Simons Island

Things to Do in St Simons Island

Frequently Asked Questions

What styles of pizza are available in St Simons Island?

Can I get good pizza for takeout in St Simons Island?

Do pizza places in St Simons Island take reservations?